Introduction
As technology continues to advance and integrate into every aspect of our lives, ethical dilemmas in computing have become more common and complex. From questions about digital privacy to the ethical implications of hacking, students must develop the ability to think critically about the consequences of their actions in the digital world.
This chapter focuses on ethical decision-making through debate and role-play, allowing students to explore multiple perspectives on real-world ethical scenarios. By analyzing different viewpoints, students will develop moral reasoning skills, understand the importance of digital responsibility, and learn to make ethical choices in technology use.
The Importance of Ethical Decision-Making in Technology
Technology has a profound impact on individuals, businesses, and society. The ethical use of technology requires considering not only what is possible but also what is right. Ethics in computing ensures that technology benefits society while minimizing harm.
Some common ethical questions in technology include:
- Should people have the right to online anonymity, or should governments monitor online activities to prevent crime?
- Is it acceptable to use artificial intelligence to create deepfake videos?
- Should companies be allowed to track users’ data for targeted advertising?
- What responsibilities do programmers have in ensuring their software is not misused?
To better understand these ethical challenges, students will engage in a debate and role-play activity to analyze different viewpoints.
Understanding Different Ethical Perspectives
Before engaging in the debate and role-play activity, students should familiarize themselves with different ethical perspectives that can influence decisions in technology:
- Utilitarianism (Greatest Good for the Majority)
- A decision is considered ethical if it produces the most benefit for the greatest number of people.
- Example: A company collecting user data to improve AI systems might argue that the benefits (better AI services) outweigh the risks (loss of personal privacy).
- Deontological Ethics (Rules-Based Approach)
- Actions are judged based on whether they follow ethical principles and moral duties, regardless of the outcome.
- Example: Hacking into a company’s system is unethical even if it exposes a flaw that could improve security.
- Virtue Ethics (Character and Integrity-Based Approach)
- Decisions should align with virtues such as honesty, integrity, and fairness.
- Example: A student who finds a security loophole in their school’s grading system should report it instead of exploiting it.
- Relativism (Context-Dependent Ethics)
- Ethics can depend on cultural, social, or situational factors.
- Example: What is considered ethical regarding internet freedom in one country may differ from another country’s perspective.
Understanding these ethical perspectives will help students evaluate different sides of a debate and think critically about their positions.
Debate Topics: Ethical Dilemmas in Computing
Students will participate in a classroom debate where they will take opposing sides on an ethical issue related to technology. Here are some debate topics to consider:
1. Is It Acceptable to Download Music or Movies for Free?
- Yes Argument:
- Information should be freely accessible.
- Artists and companies already make money through advertisements, concerts, and sponsorships.
- Some people cannot afford to pay for entertainment content.
- No Argument:
- It violates copyright laws and is considered stealing.
- Artists and content creators lose money, affecting the industry.
- It can lead to viruses and cybersecurity risks when downloading illegally.
2. What Should You Do If You Discover a Security Loophole in a Game?
- Yes, Exploiting It is Okay:
- If the company does not fix its bugs, users should have the right to use them.
- Some game glitches can be fun and do not cause harm.
- Other players may already be using it, so reporting it is pointless.
- No, It Should Be Reported:
- Exploiting security loopholes can lead to unfair advantages.
- Ethical responsibility means ensuring games remain fair for all players.
- If reported, companies may reward users who find bugs (bug bounty programs).
3. Should Schools Monitor Students’ Internet Activity?
- Yes Argument:
- Protects students from cyberbullying and harmful content.
- Prevents distractions by blocking access to games and social media.
- Helps schools identify and prevent security threats.
- No Argument:
- Violates student privacy and creates a culture of distrust.
- Schools should educate students on responsible internet use rather than monitor them.
- Some monitoring software can be inaccurate and result in unfair punishment.
4. Should AI Be Allowed to Replace Human Workers?
- Yes Argument:
- AI improves efficiency and reduces errors in industries like healthcare and manufacturing.
- AI can perform dangerous jobs that humans cannot safely do.
- Technology advancements should not be stopped to protect jobs.
- No Argument:
- AI replacing workers increases unemployment rates.
- AI lacks human creativity, emotion, and ethical reasoning.
- AI decision-making can have biases that negatively impact certain groups.
Role-Play Scenarios: Applying Ethical Reasoning
In addition to debates, students can participate in role-play exercises where they take on different roles and respond to ethical dilemmas.
Scenario 1: Reporting a Security Breach
Situation: A student finds a way to access teachers’ confidential files through a security loophole in the school system. They can either report it, use the information for personal gain, or sell the data online.
- Roles:
- Student (Hacker): Decides what to do.
- School IT Administrator: Explains the importance of cybersecurity and legal consequences.
- Other Students: Discuss how this could impact the school community.
Discussion Questions:
- What is the ethical choice in this situation?
- Should the student be rewarded for discovering the vulnerability, or should they face consequences?
- How can the school prevent such issues in the future?
Scenario 2: Social Media Influencer and Fake News
Situation: A student has a large following on social media. They receive money from a company to spread false information about a product. The student must decide whether to post it or reject the offer.
- Roles:
- Social Media Influencer: Decides whether to post false information for money.
- Company Representative: Tries to convince the influencer to take the offer.
- Followers/Consumers: Respond to misinformation and discuss the impact of fake news.
Discussion Questions:
- Should influencers be held accountable for spreading misinformation?
- How does fake news impact society?
- What are ethical responsibilities when using social media platforms?
Learning Objectives:
By the end of this lesson, students should be able to: ✅ Analyze ethical dilemmas related to technology.
✅ Understand multiple perspectives on complex ethical issues.
✅ Develop critical thinking and reasoning skills in digital ethics.
✅ Engage in respectful debate and articulate ethical viewpoints.
✅ Recognize the importance of ethical decision-making in computing.
Conclusion: Building a Responsible Digital Future
The digital world presents numerous ethical challenges, and making responsible decisions requires critical thinking, awareness, and integrity. Engaging in ethical debates and role-playing scenarios prepares students to navigate real-world technology issues responsibly.
By considering different perspectives and applying ethical reasoning, students will develop the skills necessary to be responsible digital citizens and future technology leaders.